Asked By: Ronald Jones Date: created: Nov 18 2023

Did The Watcher ever get caught

Answered By: Aaron Robinson Date: created: Nov 18 2023

As in the show’s ending, ‘The Watcher’ never got caught and the mystery never was solved – Over the course of several years, police, investigators and the FBI studied the case, examining handwriting in the letters, analyzing DNA evidence and interviewing neighbors in an attempt to connect the messages to an individual. Becca Wood Becca Wood is a news and trending reporter for TODAY Digital based in New York City. Follow her on Instagram and Twitter.

Who is the killer of The Watcher?

‘The Watcher’ Character John Graff is Inspired by Real-Life Family Murderer and Longtime Fugitive John List This story contains spoilers for The Watcher Netflix’s new series The Watcher has thrust Westfield, N.J., into the public eye. But decades before creepy letters began to arrive for the Broaddus family, a horrific crime involving a prominent Westfield family shook the idyllic suburb.

The Watcher is loosely based on the true story of the Brauddus family — who are renamed the Brannocks in the series — and the alarming letters they began to receive after purchasing the home at 657 Boulevard in 2014. However, the Brannock family are not the only characters in the series who are based on real-life people.

The character John Graff, played by Joe Mantello, is loosely based on family murderer and longtime fugitive, John List, who also lived in Westfield. In the fictionalized series, Graff’s creepy character is the former owner of 657 Boulevard, who also receives letters from The Watcher and then kills his entire family.

  • In real life, List had no connection to 657 Boulevard, but he owned a mansion in Westfield and killed his wife, mother, and his three children before going on the run for nearly 18 years.
  • John List, left, and Joe Mantello as John Graff in The Watcher.
  • Getty; Eric Liebowitz/Netflix On November, 9, 1971, List sent his children to school, then got two old handguns from his garage.

He went back inside his 19-room mansion — which was named Breeze Knoll — and shot and killed his wife of nearly 20 years, Helen List, in the kitchen. He then made his way to the third floor where his 84-year-old mother, Alma, lived in a converted apartment,,

After the pair greeted each other, he shot and killed her, too. List dragged his wife’s body to the ballroom of the mansion, then went to the kitchen and mopped the floor. When he was finished, he made himself a sandwich and ate at the kitchen table while waiting for his children to arrive home. When they did, he killed Patricia, 16, John, 15, and Frederick, 13, one by one.

According to NJ.com, the oldest and youngest were killed by a single bullet, but police believe his middle child, who was 5’9″ and 170 pounds, put up a fight. He was struck by 10 bullets. After the killings, he lined his three children’s bodies up in the ballroom next to his wife on sleeping bags.

The List family. Their bodies were discovered a month later once people began to get suspicious about the family’s absence. It took so long for people to notice because List sent letters to the children’s school saying they’d be gone for awhile to visit their ailing grandmother out of state. When officers arrived at the mansion they discovered the bodies of the children and their mother in the ballroom.

Then they found letters from List himself — including one written to his pastor in which he confessed to what he had done, NJ.com reports. In the letter, he explained that he was broke and didn’t want to subject his children to poverty, so that’s why he killed them.

  1. The confession — in addition to other notes left by List — showed how he meticulously planned the murders.
  2. I’m sure many will say how can anyone do such a horrible thing.
  3. My only answer is it isn’t easy and was only done after much thought,” the confession letter read in part.
  4. He signed off the five-page letter by writing “P.S.

mother is in the hallway in the attic – 3rd floor. She was too heavy to move.” Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. Although detectives had a full confession, List was nowhere to be found — and he had almost a full month head start on detectives thanks to his months-long planning.

Nine months after the murders, List was still not apprehended, and the house was mysteriously destroyed by a fire. The fire was ruled an arson, and the case remains unsolved, NJ.com reports. The $90,000, Westfield, N.J.19 room mansion of John List after it was set on fire. Harry Hamburg/NY Daily News Archive via Getty It was later discovered that List arrived in Denver, Colo., 10 days after the murders and changed his name to Robert Peter “Bob” Clark.

In 1985, List — who was going by a different name and age — married Delores Miller. By 1988, the married couple were living in Virginia and List was working as an accountant, NJ.com reports. In 1989, an episode of America’s Most Wanted aired featuring the story of the List murders in New Jersey.

  • Wanda Flanery — an old friend of Delores — was watching and she recognized the man on TV as someone she knew as Robert Clark.
  • She called the tip line.
  • FBI agents arrived at the shared home of Delores and Robert Clark on June 1 and knocked on the door.
  • Delores answered, but her husband was at work.
  • One of the officers stayed with her while the other rushed to where he was working.

John List was caught. “He was a strange man, I would say,” FBI Agent Kevin August said of List, NJ.com reports. “He was not very animated — that’s the best way to put it. He seemed to me as a vessel, with no soul in there.” On April 12, 1990, List was convicted of five counts of first-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison.

  • During a, List expressed regret for the killings saying, “I wish I had never done what I did.
  • I’ve regretted my actions and prayed for forgiveness ever since.” When asked why he killed his family, but not himself, he responded saying if he died by suicide, he didn’t think he’d go to heaven.
  • It was my belief that if you kill yourself, you won’t go to heaven,” he said during the interview.

“So eventually I got to the point where I felt that I could kill them. Hopefully they would go to heaven, and then maybe I would have a chance to later confess my sins to God and get forgiveness.” On March 21, 2008, List died at the age of 82 of complications from pneumonia, but the infamous story of the List murders still haunts Westfield.

What actually happened in The Watcher?

The Real Location Of The Watcher House Explained – As portrayed in Netflix’s The Watcher, the location of the actual house is 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey. However, instead of using the original location’s zip code (07090), the series changes it to 11537. Netflix’s The Watcher accurately shows that Derek and Maria Broaddus, whose names are changed to Dean and Nora Brannock in the show, bought the house for $1.36 million but were never informed about letters in the Watcher case by the previous owners.

  1. Through John Graff’s story arc, the Netflix true-crime series draws references to a real family murder, which shook the otherwise idyllic community.
  2. The vicious crime happened in November 1971, when Westfield resident John List killed his wife, mother, and three children before going into hiding (via ABC News ).

The series takes some creative liberties with its depiction of the actual home’s layout from The Watcher true story. To add layers of mystery and drama to an otherwise simple true tale, the series shows an underground passageway beneath the property, which did not actually exist in the real home.

Why is Theodora the Watcher?

ERIC LIEBOWITZ/NETFLIX – By separating Theodora from the rest of the melodrama the show is mired in—we only see her alongside the Brannocks, in neo-noir-ish settings like diners and dimly lit back rooms—she helps The Watcher maintain some semblance of grounding.

All the hysterics surrounding the Brannocks’ lives keep leading to dead ends, giving the show a screeching start-and-stop cadence. But when Theodora is back on screen, there’s some forward movement; someone is actually doing the mystery-solving here on this mystery show. And that someone is more believable than beguiling, in a show that’s mostly the latter.

When Theodora finally succumbs to her illness in the penultimate episode, it’s hard to justify watching further—the real hero is gone. The Brannocks attend both Theodora’s hospital bedside and her funeral, which is the most human they seem throughout the whole series.

  1. But before she dies, she tries to turn herself into the villain, telling Dean that she was The Watcher all along.
  2. This, however, turns out to be a lie: Her daughter tells the Brannocks that Theodora only claimed to be The Watcher in the hopes that it would give the family some closure.
  3. She didn’t want her final case to go unresolved, either.
You might be interested:  Who Is Responsible For Using A Fire Extinguisher?

The Watcher would have been better served by turning its focus toward Theodora and away from the vaguely supernatural, increasingly unbelievable main plot. There are plenty of aggrieved wealthy white people on TV as it is. How many shows can boast about their best character being a badass, true crime-loving, British-accented, Black female jazz singer-turned-private detective? The Watcher can, and it should be proud of it.

Was the Watcher ever solved in real life?

Was the true story behind The Watcher ever solved? – Several investigations took place, both by police and former FBI agents hired by the Broadduses, over the years. However, as detailed above, the Watcher was never found and continues to be unidentified to this date.

Asked By: Cole Morris Date: created: May 18 2023

Who is the biggest suspect for The Watcher

Answered By: Malcolm Gray Date: created: May 18 2023
Netflix ‘s The Watcher ends on an ambiguous note, but the series makes a good case for John Graff being the titular letter writer. Partly based on a true story, The Watcher follows the Brannock family as they move into their dream home in Westfield, New Jersey, only to begin receiving typewritten letters containing personal information and threats against them.

There are many plausible suspects presented in the series, but the most likely identity of the Watcher is the home’s previous owner, John Graff. Graff murdered his entire family in the home in 1995, then apparently fled the town, but not before cutting his face out of every family photo. The murders were only corroborated by one police file and were never reported on in the press.

Despite the murders’ status as an urban legend and The Watcher ‘s ending remaining ambiguous, context clues point strongly to a character who goes.

10/20/2022by Phoebe Solomon ScreenRant.com

Asked By: Sean Campbell Date: created: Jul 23 2023

Do they catch who The Watcher is

Answered By: Morgan Harris Date: created: Jul 23 2023

The finale: Did they ever find the real Watcher, and what happened to the house? – Murphy’s series finishes with a chilling title card noting that “The Watcher case remains unsolved.” While the seven-episode show is a work of fiction loosely based on real events, that part is true.

The person — or people — sending letters to the Broaddus family was never caught. Derek and Maria Broaddus made a home elsewhere, and it took them five years to formally sell 657 Boulevard, though renters inhabited the space for some time. The house still stands, and the listing agent who eventually sold it to a young couple in 2019 for $959,000 (nearly $400,000 less than what the Broadduses paid for it in 2014) tells EW he had to overcome significant “stigma” attached to the house in order to find a new buyer.

“That was our biggest hurdle: Trying to get over that stigma. Plus, you had people riding by the house, taking pictures, walking up to the front door, it was crazy,” David Barbosa, owner of David Realty Group, says, adding that he required potential purchasers to meet with an attorney to sign off on knowing the full history of the property before putting in an offer.

One man, whom Barbosa remembers confidently told him that he didn’t “give a s-” about the hostile letters the Broadduses received, backed out after delving deeper into the case: “He went down to the attorney’s office and called me and said, ‘Yeah, I’m out.’ He just said, ‘Listen, after reading everything, there’s no way I’m going in that house,'” Barbosa says with a laugh.

The series’ final moments expand upon the last words of the Cut article; the show ends with Dean keeping tabs on his former home and lying about his whereabouts on a phone call with Nora, who’s revealed — moments later — to be scoping out the neighborhood as well, while the article finishes with Derek admitting that the intrusive thoughts the Watcher conjured within him, even after they moved on from the house, felt “like cancer” every day. The Watcher (TV series) Based on a horrifying true story, Ryan Murphy’s limited Netflix series centers on a family who moves into an idyllic New Jersey mansion only to be welcomed by a host of oddball neighbors as they receive increasingly threatening letters from an anonymous stalker eyeing their every move.

Did the Broaddus family get paid for The Watcher?

Where are Derek and Maria Broaddus now? – Image: Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection Where are Derek and Maria Broaddus now? The Broaddus family sold the house on 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, in July 2019 for around $959,000, about $400,000 less than what the Broaddus family bought the home for, according to,

Since then, there have been no reports of the new owners receiving letters from The Watcher. The Union County Prosecutor’s Office also confirmed to TODAY that the investigation into The Watcher’s identity isn’t currently active, though the case remains open. Sowhere are Derek and Maria Broaddus now? According to, the Broaddus family decided to stay in Westfield, New Jersey, after they sold The Watcher house and bought a second home in the city using an LLC to keep the location private.

Derek is also active on Twitter under the handle, where he tweets updates on The Watcher case.”@LeaderTimes hey Horace how’s the hoax theory you started about my family holding up? I’m still waiting for my apology. #gutless @WestfieldTAP,” he tweeted a Westfield journalist in 2019 about the rumor the Broaddus family were behind The Watcher letters.

  • In October 2015, Lifetime also released a movie based on the Broaddus family’s experienced title The Watche r.
  • Though the Broaddus family sent a cease-and-desist order to Lifetime to prevent the release of the movie, the film was able to air because of how much artistic license was taken with the plot.

“The Broadduses had little interest in giving someone the right to make a piece of entertainment out of the worst years of their life,” New York Magazine reported. Despite this, the Broaddus family later came to an agreement with Netflix in 2018. Deadline reported at the time that streaming service acquired the rights to the Broaddus family’s story in a deal worth “seven figures.” Though there have been rumors that the Broaddus family was paid $10 million by Netflix for the rights to their story, New York Magazine reported that the money from the deal “didn’t even cover their losses on the house.” The magazine also reported that the Broaddus family “wanted little involvement” but had two requests.

The first was “that the show not use their names.” (In The Watcher, their characters are Dean and Nora Braddock.) The second was that “the onscreen family look as little like theirs as possible.” New York Magazine also reported that the Broaddus family “wouldn’t mind it if the fictional house burned to the ground.” As for if they’ve seen The Watcher, New York Magazine also reported that the Broaddus family haven’t seen the show and “don’t plan to watch it.” The magazine added that “seeing the trailer was stressful enough” for the family.

ABC News and Good Morning America correspondent Eva Pilgrim also reported that she contacted the Broaddus family in October 2022 but they declined to speak to her. “We reached out to the Broaddus family. They declined to comment, but they do still live here in the Westfield area.

Asked By: Carl Flores Date: created: Dec 10 2022

Was The Watcher family killed

Answered By: George Lopez Date: created: Dec 12 2022

Bobby Cannavale’s character makes a shocking discovery in an episode 3 sequence that drew inspiration from the real-life John List family murders. The Watcher Warning: This article contains spoilers for The Watcher, As if a fact-based story about a family plagued by maniacal letters from an anonymous stalker wasn’t terrifying enough, Ryan Murphy’s The Watcher series also drew narrative inspiration from a true story about a mass murder that took place in the same New Jersey town as the 2018 Cut article the show is based on.

  • Episode 3, titled “Götterdämmerung,” sees Nora ( Naomi Watts ) and Dean Brannock ( Bobby Cannavale ) delving deeper into the mystery surrounding the threatening messages that appear in their mailbox at 657 Boulevard in Westfield, N.J.
  • After the suspect pool dwindles thanks to the supposed murder-suicide of nosy neighbors Mitch ( Richard Kind ) and Mo ( Margo Martindale ), Dean discovers a religiously obsessed man named John ( Joe Mantello ) — who claims to be a building inspector working with the crew remodeling the kitchen — making a sandwich in front of his refrigerator.

Their conversation grows increasingly unnerving, with John urging Dean to take his family to a Lutheran church down the road while babbling about cyclical chaos breeding world destruction, until Dean becomes hostile and John departs. Later, Dean’s private investigator, Theodora ( Noma Dumezweni ), tells him a story about a man named John Graff, a past resident of Dean’s property who, years prior, lost his lucrative job after moving his wealthy mother in with himself, his wife, and his two teenage children.

As Theodora narrates, we see a flashback that reveals John Graff is the same present-day John who made himself a cold cut lunch in Dean’s kitchen, and we learn that his psychological descent began after he lost his job and started siphoning money from his mother’s savings account to keep up the illusion that he was employed.

Theodora continues, telling Dean that John, too, eventually received menacing letters from the Watcher, which preceded him shooting his wife in the back of the head inside the house. He later killed his mother on the second floor, waited for his daughter to return home from school before shooting her as well, and ultimately traveled to his son’s basketball game, drove him back to the house, and shot him when they walked through the door. ‘The Watcher’ episode 3 murder sequence involving John Graff (Joe Montello) is based on the real John List family murders of 1971. | Credit: Netflix; Bettmann/Getty It might seem like a fantastical, fictional bloodbath concocted for TV, but this sequence was inspired by the real crimes of John List, who, on Nov.9, 1971, killed his entire family in identical fashion within their Westfield abode.

You might be interested:  Who Plays Morticia Addams?

List similarly lost his job, and gradually bled out his mother’s $200,000 savings before killing her and his wife in the house. He also ambushed two of his children when they returned home from school, and it’s rumored that he made himself lunch between the killings, after which he reportedly traveled to his oldest son’s soccer game and shot him approximately 10 times later that night.

Police didn’t find the Lists’ bodies until nearly a month after they were killed, with police eventually entering the home on Dec.7 after neighbors voiced concerns. List left a note, indicating that he ended their lives to protect them from an uptick in evil in the world. Naomi Watts and Bobby Cannavale in ‘The Watcher.’ | Credit: Netflix List went on the run, and wasn’t captured until around 22 million people watched an America’s Most Wanted episode chronicling his crimes. A Richmond, Va. woman who saw the show told authorities she thought her neighbor, a churchgoing accountant named Robert Clark, looked like the image of List she’d seen on the program.

Agents went to the man’s home and discovered that Clark was actually List, who’d built a new life for himself in the Virginia suburbs. He was arrested in 1989, convicted and sentenced to five life terms in prison. He died in 2008 as a result of complications from pneumonia. Though the search for List — who had nothing to do with letters sent to Derek and Maria Broaddus, the real family who received the notes at their Westfield home — came to an end, the real-life case that formed the basis for The Watcher series’ fictional take remains unsolved.

Related content: The Watcher The Watcher (TV series) Based on a horrifying true story, Ryan Murphy’s limited Netflix series centers on a family who moves into an idyllic New Jersey mansion only to be welcomed by a host of oddball neighbors as they receive increasingly threatening letters from an anonymous stalker eyeing their every move.

Did the family in The Watcher get killed?

What The Watcher ‘s John Graff and John List have in common – In episode 3, “Götterdämmerung,” Dean Brannock (Bobby Cannavale) learns another dark chapter in his new home’s history. Private investigator Theodora Birch (Noma Dumezweni) unfolds the tragedy of the Graff family, who were slain by father John.

While she claims this story “is not in any newspaper article, not on any website,” the actual case is very well known to true crime fans and has been featured on episodes of Forensic Files, American Justice, and Your Worst Nightmare, Like John List, John Graff (played by Joe Mantello) seemed like an ordinary man who loved his family and his Lutheran church.

An army veteran, he became an accountant and moved his wife, kids, and elderly mother to a big home in Westfield, New Jersey. In List’s case, it was a place described by the New York Times as a “19-room ramshackle Victorian” with a Tiffany skylight. The motive for the murder — as with many family annihilators — was his shame over not being able to provide for his family.

  1. List struggled to maintain a job.
  2. To keep up appearances, he drained his mother’s bank accounts of $200,000, but was drowning in debt, including two mortgages on the house.
  3. Both List and the fictional Graff had an unhappy marriage with a wife named Helen, as well as an athletic teen son, and a teen daughter named Patricia.

( The Watcher changes the name of the teen son and excludes List’s other teen son altogether.) In both cases, this family man would murder every relative living under that roof. The Watcher lays out Graff’s crime very closely to the true story. List fatally shot his wife and mother, then laid in wait for 16-year-old Patricia and 13-year-old Frederick to return from school before killing them as well.

  1. Just as Graff takes his time to eat a sandwich in the household-turned-homicide scene, List took a break between killings to eat lunch.
  2. Then, he attended 15-year-old John’s soccer game (instead of the basketball game depicted in The Watcher ), drove his elder son home, and killed him.
  3. To keep nosy neighbors at bay, List told people the family was going away on vacation.

He left the bodies of his murdered family behind in their home, and then he disappeared. As seen in The Watcher, the killer turned on all the lights in the house and set organ music to play. Before he left, he cut himself out of family photos. It took weeks for the crime to be discovered and much longer for its perpetrator to be captured.

Asked By: Caleb Walker Date: created: Apr 29 2023

Is The Watcher a serial killer

Answered By: Austin Rodriguez Date: created: May 02 2023

The Watcher’s serial killer was inspired by a real person. You get two true crimes for the price of one in Netflix’s latest binge-worthy drama The Watcher. Its central premise, of course, was inspired by a New York magazine article about a couple harassed by a stalker after moving into their dream home.

Asked By: James Peterson Date: created: Aug 26 2023

Did The Watcher stop sending letters

Answered By: Francis Walker Date: created: Aug 26 2023

Did The Watcher keep writing letters? – According to the current owners, The Watcher hasn’t sent any letters since the Broaddus family left. reports that Derek and Maria Broaddus gave the new new owners some warning by taking a a photograph of The Watcher ‘s handwriting, along with a note telling them: “We wish you nothing but the peace and quiet that we once dreamed of in this house.”

Asked By: Clifford Garcia Date: created: Oct 21 2023

How many letters did The Watcher send

Answered By: Oswald Torres Date: created: Oct 22 2023

When you move into a new home, meeting neighbors is par for the course. But Maria and Derek Broaddus’ experience getting to know their neighbors took a turn for the strange — and haunting. After buying a home in Westfield, New Jersey, in 2014, they began receiving letters from an anonymous figure who signed himself “The Watcher.” At least four letters were sent in a year-and-a-half span.

The letter writer said their century-old house had been a fixture of fascination for his family for decades, and that he was “put in charge of watching and waiting for its second coming.” The letters eagerly spoke of the house being filled with “young blood,” likely referring to the Broaddus family’s three kids.

The Broaddus family never ended up moving into the six-bedroom, Dutch colonial revival house on 657 Boulevard, which they had purchased for $1.4 million. Instead, they rented it out and sold it in 2019 for $959,000, resulting in a significant loss. According to New York Magazine, the publication that reported out the story in a 2018 article, the new owners of 657 Boulevard have not received new letters.

Did everything in The Watcher happen?

What Is Fiction? – Netflix Besides the name changes and the number of children the family has, there are quite a lot of things that were fictionalized in the show. The neighbors were loosely based on real people, but not everything that happened in the show happened in real life to the Broaddus family.

  1. The family, in fact, never officially moved in due to the threats made regarding their children.
  2. So the events surrounding Carter’s pet ferret being killed never happened.
  3. The Broaddus family also didn’t have a teenage daughter, so the whole storyline of Ellie dating an older boy was fictional.
  4. Pearl and Jasper were based on neighbors they had called Peggy and Michael, that were the prime suspects at one point in the case but were eventually ruled out.

While Michael was described as an odd person and had a history of mental disability, he did not break into their home. The home behind 657 Boulevard also had lawn chairs that were pointed to face the back porch, just like Mitch and Mo from the show. However, the baby-eating blood cult was never real, and the character of Andrew and his wife and son was also fictional.

John Graff and the crimes he committed were also based on reality. Although the murders didn’t occur within 657 Boulevard and had nothing to do with the Watcher letters, they did occur in Westfield. Derek Broaddus, just like Dean Braddock, did become obsessed with discovering the identity of the Watcher.

However, he never sent any of the letters himself. Nor did he continue to visit the home after selling it. Karen, the real estate agent that befriended Nora and eventually bought the house after they listed it, was also entirely fictional. It took several years for them to finally sell the house, and the new owners have not heard from the Watcher.

Is Theodora lying The Watcher?

Who Is Theodora Birch? – To set the record straight, Theodora was not a person who worked on The Watcher case in real life. The real family had hired another private investigator, but he didn’t have a similar backstory to the show’s quiet star. Theodora is a retired jazz singer with an eye and a talent for investigation.

She enjoys a good mystery and often gets to the bottom of many cases that have stumped others in the past. She takes on the Bannock case because she’s curious as to why a stranger would harass the family, and she devotes herself to helping the family find the answer. Theodora serves as a plot device multiple times on the series, sharing new information that pushes the story along.

You might be interested:  Who Played Spider Man?

She is the voice of reason and the emotional caretaker of the characters. When Dean Brannock has his worst breakdowns throughout the series, Theodora is the one to set him back on course. She’s the puppeteer who pulls the strings, deciding which evidence is essential and which characters deserve further investigation.

  1. In her personal life, Theodora is a mother and grandmother.
  2. She’s a recovering alcoholic with terminal cancer and uses stories from her past to inspire Dean to continue.
  3. Her death created the most heartbreaking scene of the series, and in her final moments, she confesses to being The Watcher,
  4. Her story logically works because she was also the only character who remained level-headed and seemed to have all the answers.

But, unfortunately, she lied to give the family peace, and The Watcher’s true identity was never discovered,

Asked By: Jose Martin Date: created: Dec 14 2023

Who is the creepy person in The Watcher

Answered By: Juan Howard Date: created: Dec 16 2023

Is John Graff a real person? – John Graff may not be a real person, but he is loosely based on someone who lived in Westfield, New Jersey in the 1970s. Graff’s crimes on The Watcher come straight from the real-life murderer, John List. While List didn’t live in or previously own The Watcher house in real life, his connection to the New Jersey neighborhood is just as terrifying.

Why is the lady in The Watcher always wearing gloves?

‘The Watcher’ Costume Designers on the Show’s Private Eye With a Bold Fashion Persona “I’m a regular goddamn Murder, She Wrote,” declares private investigator Theodora Birch () to overwrought New Jersey patriarch Dean Brannock (Bobby Cannavale) in Ryan Murphy’s,

  1. But, in her pitch to identify the culprit terrorizing the new suburban homeowners with threatening letters in the Netflix mystery, the PI could be referring to her enigmatic self.
  2. She’s an Agatha Christie-type.
  3. You don’t know who she really is or where she comes from.
  4. You like her so much, and you believe she’s telling the truth.

But is she?” asks Lou Eyrich, Murphy’s longtime costume maestro and series producer. In a dark diner, Theodora makes her first impression in a vintage ’70s Lanvin trench over a black turtleneck and trousers, with a graphic-print head wrap. “She’s covered up, undercover,” adds Eyrich.

Theodora shares her colorful origin story — or spins a yarn — involving a jazz career, rehab stint and addiction to true-crime documentaries. She emphatically gestures throughout, as her spectacular Sermoneta orange gloves punctuate her storytelling. Theodora’s penchant for regularly covering her hands with sumptuous leather gloves was a Murphy directive.

“Because she never wants to leave fingerprints behind,” explains Rudy Mance, who co-costume designed the show with Eyrich. (Catherine Crabtree also co-designed episodes six and seven.) Later, Theodora’s brown gloves, with exposed stitching and white piping, help point the finger (sorry) toward Dean as The Watcher, as she dramatically reveals handwriting analysis evidence to his suspecting wife, Nora (Naomi Watts). Noma Dumezweni (left) and Naomi Watts in Netflix’s mystery anthology series The Watcher. Courtesy of Eric Liebowitz/Netflix Theodora’s trademark head wraps, also a Murphy mandate, heighten her timeless aesthetic that isn’t identifiable with specific fashion trends or eras.

  1. So that confuses you, too,” says Eyrich.
  2. The team sourced luxe textiles, like a black moiré, from Mood Fabrics, plus vibrantly printed scarves from local shops in the East Village.
  3. Ey hairstylist Tim Harvey created the elaborate braiding and flourishes, while Dumezweni tied her wraps in fittings.
  4. She is a little more theatrical and grand, but without being completely over-the-top,” says Mance.

He and Eyrich — christened “Lou-dy” by the crew — walked a balance with Theodora’s jewel tones and dynamic square and circle graphics to counter the striver Brannock family’s “new preppy” palette of lush neutrals. “She can’t be so far removed that Dean wouldn’t trust her,” says Mance.

Strategically dressing for the occasion, Theodora, in an Another Tomorrow white- and black-checked pantsuit, connects sartorially for a first solo meeting with Nora, who regularly wears all ivory while drinking red wine. “They mirror each other,” says Mance. To update Dean with newfound horrors of the family house’s history, Theodora intentionally veers from her suiting silhouettes to a pleated dove gray cape, with a pointed python-print collar peeking out.

The slow-build suspense of Theodora’s narration, and intense close-ups on Dumezweni, proves the perfect moment to showcase the piece from vintage rental house Early Halloween, a Lou-dy favorite. But it also enhances the overall mystery. “If she’s a little more bold there, maybe it’ll distract from the fact that she’s wearing head-to-toe black underneath it,” says Mance.

What did The Watcher letters say?

What Did The Real Letters From ‘The Watcher’ Actually Say? In their first letter, The Watcher wrote: “Dearest new neighbour at 657 Boulevard, allow me to welcome you to the neighborhood.” They then asked the Broadduses: “How did you end up here? Did 657 Boulevard call to you with its force within?” “657 Boulevard has been the subject of my family for decades now and as it approaches its 110th birthday, I have been put in charge of watching and waiting for its second coming.

  • My grandfather watched the house in the 1920s and my father watched in the 1960s.
  • It is now my time.
  • Do you know the history of the house? Do you know what lies within the walls of 657 Boulevard? Why are you here? I will find out.” According to, The Watcher also referenced the Broadduses two young children, writing: “Do you need to fill the house with the young blood I requested? Better for me.

Was your old house too small for the growing family? Or was it greed to bring me your children? Once I know their names I will call to them and draw them to me.” The Watcher continued “Who am I? There are hundreds and hundreds of cars that drive by 657 Boulevard each day.

  • Maybe I am in one.
  • Look at all the windows you can see from 657 Boulevard.
  • Maybe I am in one.” They concluded: “Welcome my friends, welcome.
  • Let the party begin, The Watcher.” Terrified? Same.
  • Let’s delve into the other letters.
  • In their second letter, The Watcher further detailed how they were watching the Broaddusses in their home.

“All of the windows and doors in 657 Boulevard allow me to watch you and track you as you move through the house,” they wrote. “Who am I? I am the Watcher and have been in control of 657 Boulevard for the better part of two decades now.” In other letters, The Watcher claimed he or she knew their names.

“I am pleased to know your names now and the name of the young blood you have brought to me. You certainly say their names often,” The Watcher wrote. Interestingly, they spelt their surname wrong in one letter, identifying them as “Braddus”. The Watcher also called out the family for renovating the old home before they moved in, telling them: “657 Boulevard is anxious for you to move in.

It has been years and years since the young blood ruled the hallways of the house. Have you found all of the secrets it holds yet? Will the young blood play in the basement? Or are they too afraid to go down there alone. “I would very afraid if I were them.

It is far away from the rest of the house. If you were upstairs you would never hear them scream.” They added that the house was “crying from all the pain it is going through” while the family continued their rennovations. “You have changed it and made it so fancy. You are stealing its history,” The Watcher wrote.

They also alluded to having lived at 657 Boulevard during the 1960s. “It cries for the past and what used to be in the time when I roamed its halls. The 1960s were a good time for 657 Boulevard when I ran from room to room imagining the life with the rich occupants there.

  • The house was full of life and young blood.
  • Then it got old and so did my father.
  • But he kept watching until the day he died.
  • And now I watch and wait for the day when the young blood will be mine again.” When the Broadduses eventually rented out their house out, The Watcher reportedly addressed another letter to the couple, despite the fact they no longer lived there.

“To the vile and spiteful Derek and his wench of a wife Maria,” the Watcher wrote. “You wonder who The Watcher is? Turn around idiots. Maybe you even spoke to me, one of the so called neighbours who has no idea who The Watcher could be. Or maybe you do know and are too scared to tell anyone.

What happened to the Broaddus family?

As for where the family is now? They still live near the house – Though they didn’t ever move into the house on 657 Boulevard, the Broaddus family still lives in Westfield, per The Cut. Westfield is a town just under an hour away from New York. In March 2018, Westfield was ranked the 99th highest-income place in the U.S., per Bloomberg,

Asked By: Diego Nelson Date: created: Dec 15 2023

What does the end of The Watcher mean

Answered By: Martin Roberts Date: created: Dec 16 2023

As the episode ends, a title card appears, pointing out that ‘the Watcher case remains unsolved.’ According to Bobby Cannavale, that fear of never being able to trust again is what consumes Dean in those final moments. ‘That sense of paranoia has seeped in,’ he says. ‘You just never know. Everybody can be a suspect.